Blog

It’s a question that came up again recently in our prophetic artist community, and it breaks my heart every time because it causes such unnecessary angst.

One of our artists shared her struggle after running a “Paint and Praise” workshop for her church community, a beautiful gathering where people painted and worshipped together at a cost of $15 per person. Despite barely covering materials and room hire, she was told by someone that “you should not make money from a Holy Spirit gift”, extending that notion to sales of her prophetic artworks.

Sound familiar? If you’ve ever felt that slap in your face or knot of guilt in your stomach when someone suggests your prophetic art should always be free, you’re not alone.

So, what do the Scriptures actually say about artists, ministry, and money?

The Heart of the Matter

The verse that seems at the heart of this confusion is Matthew 10:8: “Freely you have received, freely give.”  The Greek word translated as “freely” in this verse is “dōreán” and is defined as “without a cause; freely; for nothing, for naught or in vain, gratuitously, a gift”.

This verse has often been cherry-picked and used out of context, often to manipulate good people.

‘Cherry-picking’ verses is a decades-old practice known as ‘proof-texting’. Proof-texting involves using isolated verses to affirm specific beliefs and ignoring the historical and cultural contexts of biblical texts. This type of selective biblical interpretation serves to legitimise pre-existing authority structures rather than genuinely seeking scriptural truth, and the “specific beliefs” often vary across denominations.

In the context of Matthew 10:8, Jesus instructs His disciples to heal the sick, raise the dead, and cast out demons, all acts of divine grace that they received without cost. The verse embodies the idea that the blessings, healing, and salvation granted by God are not commodities to be exploited for personal gain, but to be shared generously with others without expecting anything in return. This sounds so good, it is not a bad thing!

Christians connect this principle beyond Jesus’ context of healing and deliverance to other biblical teachings that advocate for selflessness and service. The Church calls for all believers to leverage their gifts, whether spiritual, material, or emotional, for the benefit of others. Whether we sing, play an instrument, dance, preach, minister, prophesy, counsel, teach, or paint… we serve the Church with our gifts to advance the Kingdom from a place of genuine love. This is something we all aspire to.

However, back to the context of Matthew 10:8. Just two verses later, Matthew writes that Jesus told the disciples they had every right to expect their needs to be met by the recipients of their ministry: “For the worker is worthy of his provisions” (Matthew 10:10). When taken in context, it is clear that “Freely you have received, freely give” is not suggesting Christians work for free!

“Take no bag for the road” was also a specific word for those disciples, not a universal command for all in ministry. Look at Paul’s ministry to the Gentiles. He did not receive a command to travel without money, meaning he arranged for his financial needs to be met.

In Corinthians 9, he writes: “For it is written in the law of Moses, ‘You shall not muzzle an ox while it treads out the grain.’ Is it oxen God is concerned about? Surely he says this for us, doesn’t he?” (v9, 10). “If we have sown spiritual things for you, is it too much if we reap your material things? If others have this right of support from you, shouldn’t we have it all the more?” (v11,12) “Even so the Lord has commanded that those who preach the gospel should live from the gospel.” (v14).

Paul is abundantly clear that he expected and received financial compensation for ministering in the gifts of the Holy Spirit.

Not all circumstances in prophetic art ministry are the same. They vary as widely as the artworks themselves. As you seek the Lord for the answer regarding your own ministry, He will surely lead you. It is a personal decision between you and God alone.

The Radical Distinction

In the case of applying these Scriptures to prophetic artists, we are not even talking about preaching the gospel or delivering prophecies for financial compensation. No, we are talking about the exchange of a physical item for money—a sale.

This is the key that unlocks this whole dilemma: Separate the prophetic message from the physical artwork. We need to separate the gift of prophecy and the prophetic message in our art from the physical property of the painting.

I have said this many times before, but it is worth repeating.

The prophetic message, the ‘word’ on our art, our service to the congregation when we paint in worship, this we give freely. Unless you are an itinerant prophetic art minister who receives an offering or an honorarium, there is no payment for an artist to paint in a worship team, and the expenses to serve usually come from our own pocket. And ALL are welcome to receive freely. However, the artist owns the artwork.

The artist owns the physical painting. If someone else wants to own the artwork, to physically take it home for themselves and put it on their wall, then the painting has a price. The artist has the right to determine the price of their work.

Think of it this way: the prophetic word is free, the prophetic experience is free, but the canvas, paint, and the years invested in skill development – those have a monetary value.

No one has the right to tell you what you should do regarding selling your artwork, not your client, your family, nor your pastor. If you feel led to give your work away, that too is your right. However, you are not “more spiritual” or “more anointed” than your ministering brothers and sisters if you give away your work, and especially in the case of feeling manipulated into doing so.

A little more context: Church is not a ‘show’ that you pay for, and the musicians play for free in worship, but if you want to take the music home, you pay for the recording (in some form). The pastor preaches for free, but if you want to take his words home, you pay for his book. Personal ownership involves a financial transaction.

To single out the visual artist as someone unworthy of wages for their work for your personal edification is unfair treatment. It creates a double standard, and it’s discrimination. Most congregation members would be horrified at the thought of an inconsistent standard that genuinely disadvantages their visual artists.

What Other Prophetic Artists are Saying

Grace Bailey challenges us to think bigger: “If Christians continue in this lie that receiving payment for work done in the name of God is wrong, it automatically means that the standard and the quality of art produced by Christians will always remain amateur. Charge properly for your work, and continue to be able to devote the time to it that Kingdom business deserves!”

Kim Hogan captures it perfectly: “I do believe the word itself is always for the person God has given the word for, so I will always share with the person what I am seeing and hearing from the Lord. But to create the art piece is a service. It takes my time and my money to get the materials. Plus, it draws from my lifetime of learning and growing in the skill to create the art. These are all things that deserve compensation. I share the vision of what I’m seeing, but if they want the art piece I created, that is like a commission.”

Jan Atencio asks direct questions: “Is the Pastor paid to bring the word? Is the Worship director paid to lead worship every Week? Do missionaries receive support to fulfil their calling? Yes. Art supplies can be quite costly, and it helps not only with costs when we sell art, but it also encourages an artist when someone deems their work worthy to buy. When someone purchases something, they tend to put more value on it and the message it brings them.”

Judie Richardson offers wisdom on commissioned prophetic work: “Commissions take into account the amount of money you wish to invest in the artwork, medium, size and detail. A small pencil work on paper will cost much less than a large acrylic canvas, but the message or prophetic word will remain the same.”

Adaia Schultz addresses the deeper issue: “I think that anything that has to do with money is a heart posture thing. All good gifts come from God. The gift of creativity to paint comes from God. Not even factoring in the prophetic side, would we say the same thing to an Architect or an Engineer who was Christian? I don’t think we would. They, too, are filled with the Spirit of God.”

The Biblical Foundation for Artists

The very first person to be filled with the Spirit of God mentioned in the Bible was an artisan.

“See, I have called by name Bezalel, the son of Uri, the son of Hur, of the tribe of Judah. And I have filled him with the Spirit of God in wisdom, in understanding, in knowledge, and in all kinds of craftsmanship, to make artistic designs for work in gold, in silver, and in bronze, and in the cutting of stones for settings, and in the carving of wood, that he may work in all kinds of craftsmanship.” (Exodus 31:1-5)

Bezalel means “under the shadow, protection of God.” This should give us a definite sense of the importance that the Lord places on art and artists.

The Lord has had a lot more to say about art and the church, and I’ve covered the topic widely in my book, The Prophetic Artist: Raising an Army of Artists (available through Amazon).

Finding Your Balance

Your prophetic gift is precious and should be stewarded well. The word you receive from God? Yes, that’s free. The skilled artwork that carries that word? That has value – and there’s nothing unspiritual or unscriptural with recognising that value.

I have two little personal stories to tell you, stories that knocked these ‘sacred cows’ out for six, stories that remind me to seek the Lord first in these matters.

Someone came up to me after I had finished painting at church and said words to the effect, “That painting has so much meaning for me, it must be mine. You should give it to me”. I didn’t know how to respond and lamely answered, “Let me think about it”. Mind you, many people have told me the depth of meaning a painting carries for them, and I have felt led to give it, but this time it was as if the Holy Spirit tapped me on the shoulder and said, “Don’t you dare!” Sitting back in my seat, I randomly opened my Bible, and the page fell to Matthew 7:6. Do not give dogs what is sacred; do not throw your pearls to pigs. Quite confronting! At the end of the service, someone else messaged me saying, “Your painting speaks so much to me, please don’t sell it to anyone else. Please let me pay you twice your price.” Sometimes, when the Lord is teaching you a truth, He is crystal clear.

Another time, at a worship night where I’d painted three pieces, I came back to my easel after praying for people, and my husband had given away every painting to a group of young people. Not that unusual, as my husband is big-hearted and we genuinely love seeing people blessed, but on this occasion, I didn’t feel good about it. I asked the Lord, “What just happened?” He said, “You and your husband have a generous heart, but in this, sympathy and empathy have been confused with compassion.” This sent me into a deep dive with the Lord about His compassion and how He viewed our kind-hearted but impulsive action of giving the art away.  My husband’s sympathetic ear certainly moved him to an action that showed his thoughtfulness and his desire to meet the needs of young people; however, it missed the commitment and responsibility involved in true compassion.

I admit this took some time for me to understand. It’s the difference between impulse giving and thoughtful stewardship that considers everyone’s well-being and growth. Compassion considers the broader implications: What did this teach people about the value of art? What expectations did this set in motion regarding serving the church? How did this affect other artists?

This generous act did not take into account the long-term benefit of teaching people to value artistic work, to honour the prophetic calling on an artist’s life, or to respect the investment of time, materials, and service to the church. It sounds wonderfully spiritual, but it esteemed neither these young people nor the artist. I always said God is an economist—as a light-hearted way of saying He works for the enrichment and encouragement of all in the one moment. Everyone wins in God’s scenarios.

This experience helped my husband and me to distinguish between types of giving and understand how to turn spontaneous good intentions into even more thoughtful stewardship. It was an illustration of how natural generosity needs wisdom to become truly compassionate actions.

The take-home message is that no one outside of you and God has any input on how you price your artwork. Whether you’re using it as a blessing gift, covering only material costs as a hobby artist, or pricing as a professional, that’s between you and the Lord.

The enemy wants to burden you with confusion, guilt and shame about your gift. Sometimes the enemy uses words in the mouths of your brethren. Don’t let religious thinking dim the light God has placed within you.

You’re not simply an artist – you’re a Kingdom builder, and Kingdom work deserves Kingdom support.

Paint with freedom.

Create with joy.

May God lead you in every brushstroke – including the price tag.

What’s your heart telling you about this topic? Have you struggled with guilt about selling your prophetic art? Share your thoughts in the comments below. Share this blog with your friends, it is an important conversation to continue together.